0111911! from the record of thel l -. Dlfeltrnhe debate. g h I ga1lH?gl3Di1P38g;56 .. - ".3 apinrgtdanner in w ich cosure, ues y. 0V. , . E Offered A Dukedom Again 2. The Speaker's action on June , l. as stated by then Pro ' lnvgr I ' SIESSIVC g . names?-:2" '”' des””y'"5 P" lC0n.lEPVallVE- Leader Drew in his 31' FRASER WIGHTON The 0 .-!- . . g , censure motion, of "subordlnating, , icessor Sir Anthony Eden in tho violategpobzlnltztn auaLilrar:edntl:tees tltlalia line rights of the House to the willl argnclhggzlt lggzullehrgtl S; 5.99?!”-5i series'o.f' votes over the. Middle 10” standing ludmnm min the fzovcrnment. imProPei'lyIChm.cm" M” rem? Immlnhtglillast crisis. Drocedeuts. They quoted thcvrule lrievemgg .-a decision ."'"'0"' M" House of Commons on his tlllnsll "9 i' rewned physiuny m End book and lubbmk aumormu m ce an vlithout refusing to allow binhday NW 30 ” iappcars healthy, though his walk "pm" of mm The government members to address the House on. ' ' is ghgkier mg; of aid, and the Speaker did the same inloccmlons whe" ll" "ll?! Dl”0Vld- If he does. political quarters re- . . dgfgm-pg N UIOY had U16 Tllhl 10 be llflfd-" gard it as certain that Queen Eli-'".5eh"rc(I"" r'iS.'Sl:el!l "'9 M" M ' be”, -11 ' If h ; l 5 0 any in or many years. ROOT 0? MRTTER - g J. Thegactlte role of the bpeaker gllmesmgi, lg": fed? t C erazj was only at the desire of the to”: l::Tle:r(e'iI H '”?”'d d"'"' m "g"1"g.a8a'"5' ”PP”5"'”" Pmwwould carryawitli it amsear inltcheloueen that he Eccepted ' kn-mm u ' d d "d n; pl l inti-rpictalinvi and Ctdural points, on contrast to them, ( LO hood of the Order of the Garter. will!!! POI! IV V choice of precedents tn ' t fh relative il - 1 "" ” 'd5- 1 - - v ""”d9'l' nu” " u 9" PIFUCUIIF Emu" The gill:-liliincni There sirftgrtee olllllheer goCvl'ellllCrI2:lIlI.lL Meanwhile n f 1' f Bmams highest Md” of emula- ' I I - . ' , O CUT! lrTTl' l Tl ' . erunent and opp!!!” had the numbers to win IN way, some quite involved. but thesei e reports is 0I)laln8l)ldP oirnfnl " Ch"."cl"” "5”9"-id ' 5"” However. the real trouble was were the main ones. sources close to Churchill.A mem-l "mi "'5 "my ””' R"d9lVh- not so much OH?!" clean - cutl lber of his household told of them Vmuld bemme t' I""q""5- charges of rule violations as over Trallp ,M""5l9" H”"9r Pill” "7 today said "It's new i -:m...?..jm..m .. "10 Wly the rules were imposed. the p'pel'"9 bl”- 0P9"9d debate A cblumnlst inthe Losflflllllrl Illiil particularly the ch...-, m,,,,N,,,, May it on the mini introductory M,” "y, ,,;m ,, .. rm; whiff TWO rvres 0V9I'-FUIIMZ of 0PP0SltlDn attemptsl"”"'"””"' first 0' 7""? 33885 Dflperl that Churchill will retire on to aging, poms of order andmassage. This had been precededlhis birthday. flhrastwn cad" i' "MN" m" Christmas Day Royal Broadcast LONDON tlleutersl--The Qu - V will make her traditional Chris . mas Day broadcast from .... ilngham. the BBC announced F day. it will be made at the us time-3 p.zn. GMT til a.m. AST The round-the-world program greetings to the Queen. which pr ' codes her message. will end wt -4 the voice of the Duke of -- . burgh. l He will be speaking from royal yacht Britannia, steami ' between New Zealand and torcticn. six snails up up cuaauii 11.”. .( y en. lsupportcr of his protege and suc- )i on. This story dc!-lo with the 30!- ersl outline of tho bottle. OTTAWA (Crib-A tassklbli: lgy point of oppoo on a c next federal election already is on tho books. it is the claim that du the DREDGE AT WORK IN SOURIS been above Is the "New Bruns- BOR WESTERN STREAM l. . ,, Win! and widening the l area. Three tugs. Glen Livet ii. I at i of Parliament the - -I b I 3 , . I lick. Nguio dredgo at work inland clearing sway the silt fill- ll Margaret Porter. and the Samuel s.pggg::'::liiig commons and his ET,1;;,e5:'mS2;' ms0,::;. gzivtaeblllei o)v,era Srgpilfff (I)lIFo(leI?eura;0:lEgl.'::- suppomm; EDEN ' Wane"? mi "'3" which my 7'" NIW3 RI"-"' "0" 75 31"” urn u.r when it is deep- In in the vicinity of the dock T are in attendance. deputies, under prossuro by the .t a”. ' d 9 nient's action in producing thisl After ' f I til 4 - km" " msh " 175 (eel 1" 3m” "M" Nlmh 11"." in "” K3m19”9'" loummut um "waned b, in Pom” 0' "MN Ind pmnege. resolution Ind "M pmceedingmom ms zkeziesmonh enogf ,l!7rr::t:- ish Columbia. district of British Columbia. 1 majority. msnipullted "ll" usually take precedence over alltwml ' 'Im”3l' 0"? it hadiChurchill has recently resumed Cal-J . ' procodun to government sdvan- dug I -P""ll9d 5'” ll F9bl'UBl'y- most relzular attendance in thel . . evea S ' eiai S .........l.. comuve ..l::.f":.::."”;:.;::.:"i;.: ':.".:::; we-r W C”'""""''' "' W -Wis g - Ind CC? parties uh.” Wm nnk were prubgbly fhg Ito!-"nest At "'9 Cndulil his speech, Mr. l this claim with the cry Hill 111.9 "gnu eve, ,,,,.m,5"d m I (-mag Hows laid tit is obvious thstin days of debate on s sin lel ' 3 falbetltlho that! T90 I:eWnl1”:'co':: dian parliament, was the dE'hale- fgrle mteimbff 9”!" '0 Obstructlclause of a hill-Laiirier recallgedl OBI: I 93' mm C0 limit'ng d ” I I 1 ” 3 mo 011 0 BDPFDVE the sec- hi 1911 d ' l ' - I a r P pntuuv '3o''-.mW" '35 "to" bC9lIlllS?fTP(:lll(Ff)llflV ;l:.l's:lTel)r?Ill'f1l3;il-onihui remluuonl "3"l9l'Il13n debate WTJZGJI emsmn with mesei . our Kuhn: Plant is now operatmg- Buying . um" undoubkdly '1" occasions by Canadian -)10l'el'n- :!ti'ngl2' glspgggznhrealh-hheloriz "Heaven is mv HIIIIPSS that l Chicken and F031 daisy except Saturday Chicken ' o o . , p- I p. . mom or - - g ' . l Pwm mmn.. pipdm ments the last time In 1912 The gm 8 would "me, MM hm may. Rail Gra e or resse basis Fowl Live or Rail CANTERBURY. England tReu- ters-British and French armed action in Egypt foiled . sum” "'85!" Plan to intervene militar- ily in the Middle East. former Conservative MP John Baker Wliito said here Friday night. The Russians had already named the plan "Operation Mons" because the soviet coin- manii headquarters in Egypt wen announced it was sending "volun- tecrs" to help the Egyptians. in bet these "volunteers"-- largely air force, tank and artil- lery experts-had been already se- lected and concen rated for many months past. They would have been led by two generals - Maj.-Gen. P. l. Pinchuk. tank commander. and air force Lt.-Gen. Braiko, assist- . nianufacture. which were ishailed in parks in Egypt. Britain had no prior knowlodgs of disco weapons. non was over and nbovo tllo So- lviet and Czech material issued to the Egyptian si-my." Wbito said. around the fringes ol tho British supply base in point to debate as fresh evidence at this. They contend that after 10-odd yosrs in offics and with its his mglorny, the government now governs by force. trsmpllnt PI!" llgmenrs rules and traditions. CAMPAIGN WEAPON . Repeated oppositio chslleiilzes in sir immediate general election on the pipeline issue and all its mar- "Thii mass of armor and un- Tlie material was concsntrstod tho canal sane. Liberals eniploycd ll four times to push the pipeline hill to pass- age. Closure had been used in the past to end prolonged debate, in some cases after several months of delay. This time it was used to ensure enactment of the hill between May ll when it was presented. and the government's June 7 deadline for making a ken In debate--he gave noiice' of closure. : The opposition was astounded. then incensed. They flung back at the govern. ment the words of condemnation voiced by two great Liberals when Conservative governments had used closure. Sir Wilfrid Lau- rier said it was ”holding a terror over our heads." Mackenzie King defeated and in opposition b IPPQII to the pcopie than over there in office of the gag." But the Liberals nf 1956 werel not deterred by these voices from the past. l y that . stand .- by the power i Grade basis. Paying top market prices. Producers Co-oporatlvo Ass'n Llmltod. 60 Fitzroy Street, City said "with that weapon they strike at the very heart of the House of Commons . . . stifling discussion." l t' th upon that ii2i""cZ:.'."?5.il?.'! ...7l no car consider this I maid! Clmlllllll weapon. I The govebrnm&nt'Ic0lIlP9l1M' .u,,pon.d y . mmons Liberal: and is Social Credit momberl. was passed. but only after a bitter procedural fight waged against it by the 75-mem- ber Conservative-CCF STOUP. ll" lied on this issue. During the hectic three weeks of the fight last May and -WM the opposition forced 70 vole! 0! multl-million-dollar loan towards the trans-Canada natural gas pipeline. And. in the lace of opposition filibuster threats. the government took the unprecedented step of- brinxing closure intti play even before debate had started. CLOSURE RULES Under closure, a cabinet minis-y ter gives notice of closure one day and moves the motion the next. When approved, it halves the length of speeches to 20 minutes each. fixes I time limit of about ant chief of the Russian sir staff. Another loader would have been Lt.-Gon. Vlndilnlar Janko, former tank brigade commander in tho lst Czechoslovak Army Corps. Soviet ” lun s" were to be flown in by way of nirfields in Syria. additional landing strips for Sovistv transport plane: were to have been put down on the plain between the Syrian towns of Hams and l-isms. Equipment was ready and wait- ing in Egypt. White said. to be at the Mann House liotd, near the pyramids and adjacent to Cairo west airfield. ho told I gutted Nations Association meet- g. White said all his information some from unofficial sous-cos but .. he is convinced it is true. saying the operation was to bo "of brutal simplicity." Whito claimed these were the details: Russian army leaders appreci- gf sled that in tho interests of self- ,&i;esei-votlon Israel would be .. und sooner or later to attack This explained why British civil- ian personnel in the base were or- rested by the Egyptians - "they knew too much." white declared: "Tho volunteer force would have boon flown ll accompanied by Sovlot bolls" -. if the Israeli force had occupied the canal area or had gono fur- ther toward Cairo and Alexandria. the 'volunteer-' lorco would have been more than sufficient to drive them back. "Then the iron grip of Iovid llur customers call dais the best winter tire ever! When Laurier was prime min- ister in 1911 and a government bll had been blocked for six months by s tenacious Conserva- tive opposition he preferred to call an election. which he lost, rather than impose closure. r I. -;ii:. xw" is we SUBURBANITE --wlntor flro I0 And when closure was first ap- plied in the Canadian Parliament by Conservative Prime Minister" I ' o hhhh i industry moat sharply: Should .. .. doin since ho I Scandinavian mink bo hilowod to l.l'.gyno.:mcol',':::':r: '"""l"' "mm" "mm'' inons arbiter in 1963. He had :;:19'5p:;1dth.yP(Ou!;9.tlTrQ'l-Ill. pro that l with free trade principles, or should ' rnink's prestige; high fashion re- . who still have heavy mink stocks r a r . tivo members if freo trade is sup- ; ported. Also. all makers turning out commercial and split-skin mink of usin all 0 acetlmo is Vatican City. Tho . l . .-mi. i. .. . ..'.:.'.'2f.':.”.::."."l.::: cm am an M vw-d.bv. ”l'.i”.i .2”:-2'” TAK E ---W conttnuliig flow of inexpensive um quality will p.y on innud anyone 'WIlo makes sttsmpts upon ''-I”” L?” 5:! ff". s( L3: '.iesnn”' "lmw "l ::wM'l' son-19'"? Iw,...loiilmvf9'” . pelts Into this country from of putting pressure on producers "'9 "'9 M uhny 0' "E. mpnn. 0" '" Pt I" dnhlis resignation And music: all tv"',,"3 NOV l”"7m.”'s tur T”'.”'”h'hk :bl;0!:ldo.u'RIdll.t!:;:rb;I'EtI,.J..r11l:;:u: :3 curltoll or destroy the produc. l.!:1tniiTl' is liable to the death pQ- -;::'e'r' ':':,i::' am, Mm-9 up; N O f,'.':eLW"i;:l.,i , v;'lz":;3lhK- "'” Ha gmmll i - ,o ' . a . - i lion in the domestic msrkell. This oi? d)lre'c'I:dr"lbw1;ei'll5'geIlllnmom g”"' ' ""'"'l"5 "'""b" "I "d' mm": M dtlcomollie opmlllinn :l('tmI'-'"wt'leill:&”mw luumtul" "'63-holllgi l threat could lead to a serious osctlon. K P l"II5. led by I dlltlllllllllhd 1IV- "ml is .mmd wont spun l stabilized 'g oil l:5nnewi”"” "" break in the current mink prion iyer and senator. Glwlllll 75' cBo.slIiTi.oinlo impartiality? On what guIl.' Tm" by H”illm!":,n. ' "VIII 3"". 9 structure. The importation of oi- some time this month eel "ml "1 "mu for '1" .'”lm" did it base its charges that the in slim uo64MWc..oo':ul",. '"'" ,,,f.. ovurhf-'tl"',:,." - inotil 1 million ScsnutiJn:hvisn skins trade and protectionist factions '::.',::'f,;';”'4”".'"'”l " ""' ",3. fl'i9.un3;g-Si xvii" ”'. cu: :n;','f,"..'fl.?-::(;ivet'',';';5l1l'3liier. - as year scccntua Is throat. will d tcs!- rind” . A ' eta, . ': o i 1 civil ' i ' A -top must ho null. or tho local prelon?ct.'.I.oI,n tl':spY::l':'lenKd::eslbT- '” mm” '0 I” ” yum I M.” ,0. W I :””Ma?3gv iliiliu-n.3"; ',l,;1'.i.'i'ii-':vc"';";,l.'..."”.?lr'-Ir Hi" markot will lie giultsd. seriously foro Ibo Tariff c ' ' nu. V"”.Tilov""X1indu .uld his .r9"”' ”: on .-Inlllfl-II tho American mink tlliig for some form of rot tl ' oft "M. us!” "' 7:1” 9”" H ., mm, . M M A P cc on sill? pass so IWIDII I I- avg ,,.,,.ud ,. - nierlcan mink rancher TORONTO (cp m A ,,,,.d 5 ;m -. a ll - at l L in la v ' food sources bacon t The Scsndino.vri'sh hnsu'no.c.sli?h. Aszoncihlllgdypufli Ms.::;:iEl .Co:ekm;";:,d"d mm. I” an" '"'''r this side of tho arsiinle i. And ' "' No-llsltlilovnofvlalrlut fl MW" at the Board of - :- :... Fm- r Wkhd 5!! Fsrrn Organisations is slated to XIX i H .. J I I-QIVC and I-GIAI... I-HIS!-V', In-QIICI-V C s than: who tho only gosllo Lssfo-have this involves in In ' w.:-::i:.-.4-"-it-::.r..: :p:.':;:t"-:--6-t'-'-' Toronto club which hm ' ' 'mkhhm- : "I'll: V” W '3' 9'! a.;'r:"c'i-llstet to Ian. . J ' ",,1:,?,, """ 'W,',";,';'.,'.',L'.,.l.'.'..,'”"..'.,' soonusovossicsusssi loans is..o..u.v.u-o.-- out-us-un sisususamm--asn-no-' I -w-.l';",":L'I-- H.r.:.:':.-.-........"-"'- of kw." 1 a...-"'"".' "M-. :'.”.:-':il"r....... '3 I-lI.l.MAN oisnistnos- ' an ---”-'-t-.-33'-...-;-': ' MARTIN'S ems: QHIUD , """"""-mu.-n I i ''',,,,"'',,.,,,..'''''''''i'"' 1 3”: 9,... 1l46ooos Cooisosdsooouisloctlosofllsodcors : 3.. - hr '35 M 3'ul2l8' i if ' ,-I. . . K I, L tho Soviet government would hovo ITMELY NOTES ON Hill TOPICS one of her neighbors rlggmbntlgrftlbgs already have zlimtoll-sVll)f:lll!num:f.tbo ll" l""l'"”"' Twemrfour "I 10 hours on debate and then forces Sir Robert Borden-in 1918 after m crvrs nnrsua ' disclosed there were large llllln- world." ”"'fh '”;'m'"”''' M” "M" a vote. - m , As the Israeli attack developod born of tanks. self-propelled sun! Three things contributed I0 ”.1.m:"";.u '0, mnm pmmpged Rules of Parliament are numer- .1-unjmx-1: & fl and rocket batteries, all of Soviet: ii f in H HI "' W 'l”'- ' ' d t.. Til the STANDARD TIME 0M. of the 1051"! mini We '3""-"'' ""95" :lpeI:'?nVf'hll)e nailed. mm ' '0 """ """','”' ”l,,"'.',,'”",3,,,'l,”,lg; gTlihdlncgonOlll1cefl. 'rh:;.Ir-"r.evlIed For daily report dial crcv .- um '"”" 1"" "wed mwlrd "The Hungarians pisyod their ll" "W" on 5 from time to time, the mast rei:- fun "um" hmldclm ufacturera in the United States has tossed I promotional bomb- sliell into the fur market by ad- vertising mink costs at 81.650. "Scandinavian mink". his coat- petitors ,cliarged. Ho readily sd- . mc,nLy iuI;G,uu)l:D g g l" '":'t. "W: "' le5'-”?-?i'33l'- 'r'l-'"l-'n3lfl1J"lE5: lam: ” .::":..l:;: 22::...r::::;:....'r. .;'".'.:'.i...:::. N.9Er;;mmmERmND V”L,f;';iZ.'3,GNgi”” Duo in man this promoton pon up o n t M ' ' H” t 1:1,. a II any W0 none to ' M issue that is now dividing the fur '” "M ” 'm' M e r Curr” H9 b9"'"d "" An” re” rulings by Speaker Rene Beau- 313933: licnfterpretmom of me” Charlottetown. P. I. Island I flow into this country In keeping the domestic ranclior be protected In some way against foreign in- cursions? The market is in process of choosing sides. Generally speak- ing, the lineup runs something like this: favoring some protection on the ranchers. of course: some high fashion makers who fear cheap mink imports will lower tsllers who feel the sum was high fashion makers; some dealers and four having to soil at a loss- Freo trade advocates include msjor association leaders in tho dealing and manufacturing fields who fool mink prices will he "moro realistic" for their rupee- roon cosnv Tho United States rancher can't match the Scandinavian on the cost front. Not only is food gat- Ulll hlgb hero, but is some cases froo trade since the inception of the reciprocal trade era under Cordell Hull. The Issue cant be confined to the fur sltuqtion. It involves relations between the United States and other nations. predicament but themselves. They to Scandinavian ranchers - and even told their customers that the United States would prove a ready customer for their production! The ranchers can rectify the situ- ation without getting Government help. All they have to do is con- centrate on a quality product and eliminate commercial production. Let the Scandinavians have the cheap mink market. The Government has been cod- dlllll tho ranchers far too long. Just because shippers have a "Will lobby doesn't Justify every Drotc.-tlonist move they make. Supply and demand is the life- blood of the dealing Industry, and tho ranchers shouldn't be allowed to stifle s free economy. Tho rsnchsra are wasting their energy flying to get Government support for their current praiect. Instead will be the National Board of Fig: Form Ornsniutions. The free trade advocates will be represent. ed by several elements. The American Fur Merchants Assocl. otion almost certainly will join the throwing "Operation Mona" out of gear-the swtftneu of tho loroall attack on Egypt. tho Anglo-French intervention with armed and the decisive attacks of French air forces on tho I airflelds the Russian sir would have used. part because the Soviet high com- mand had hoped that as '0puu- tlon Mena' was launched, this massive concentrations of arms: in Europe would have made it im- possible for us or the Amos-leans intervention saved Egypt from ho lfalian Movo To Abolish life imprisonment abolish life imprisonment in gain- ing support in Italy. WM" "'3 penal code already is small! 00 world'I fude to murder- In Italy after tho collapse of foo- clsm in 1944. But even durln Fascist regime. only those guilty of particularly atrocious murders were condemned to death and executed by a firing Muld- peninsula when a porson can he condemned to death legally in ship this bus to luropo teriollze Saturday whsd W mall- mouthed black roi-ito's Maiton Airport on 1 plus trip to Sweden. Tho fish will go by air via Toronto. New York and CC! Loader Coldwell. as. he an- nounced yet another appeal. to re- mark in frustration: "I iiilillt we must be right occl- slonslly . . . Mr. Speaker. I think you are human like the rest of us and that you on. In some of these "The mm W" an "manna rulings I think that right has been this ..gumeiit: That wi-out rul- ings made under partisan stress and confirmed by House WW may become embedded as Pl” 0' Commons custom and be used 10 justify future wrong rulInE!- wos made Com- ous and complex. Their applies tion is made difficult by the nec- essity of interpreting them in the light of constantly changing cir- cumstances. There are simple rules laid down for day-to-day application in respect to concrete situations and tho mechanics of parliamen- ent revision occurring with unan- imous approval in 1955. To aid in meeting special situa- tions. the Standing Orders are supplemented by volumes of so- called citations and interprets- WOIJII ISLAIIIIS-lllllllilll FERRY SEIWIGE Oct. 21 to Nov. so Daily from oach terminal: I s.m.y 11 a.rn., 1 pm.. 3 pm. Catch an early crossing and avoid delay. Reservations Limited For particulars contact: J; 1 ISLAND WHITLUCK . TIRE SERVICE eolnolobonoglrdodinnll pul- ltieai ouwrtors as one of the best speak - in Canadian parliamen- tsry iiimry. rile uxye-Mid M- tlvo of Quebec in fluently bill!!- sl. Kubut his conduct during the Pill? line debate prompted the OPPOSI- tion to move a censure motion against him, the first in a Cans- dian parliament. He was repell- edly accused of favoring the Lib- oral majority. the party to which he belongs. Never beforo had a Commons presiding officer faced so many challenges of his iudgment. I0 many oral attacks upon his con- duct, so much clamomus disor- der. His position eventually became so lntoiorsbld that. after the PIM- ltilo bill was passed and the can sure motion defeated. he submit- ted his ieslgnsti in a statement qsiiying that his rulings over had ROME (Reuters) - A move to most lenient in its atti- Tho death penalty was sbolilllld l...'i'.i The only place on tho ltollnl will no- bass ioovo To defend the interests of its mem- bers. The issue. as noted. in whstlior American mink rolchern should be protected against for sign competition. in the context a the current controversy. "foreign" means Scandinavian. la far as th muoui loordla hko bold-boost you along any wlntor road-looso mow. pscksd snow, was In (sod of ooni-so mud). a "hot seat." as Deputy speaker W. A. Robinson described it. At another juncture Mr. Bonu- doin's other deputy. Chsinnan E. T. Applewhalte. said he consid- ered his only responsibility was "not to rule upon tho merits or demerits of a motion. not to rule upon the desirability of otherwise of procedure or of a standing or- der. but to try to come to I con- cluslon as cold-bloodedly as I can. . POINTS OF CRITICISM With this setting. these salient points of opposlti criticism YOU QUALITY 1IUIlsO&& lash up-anon-s-I &