i l: 10v

_ H. illiJiiiillN SHUWS P liiffifiiiiiii iililiiiifi

five years. 0i’ course we can uiily sily that we may do it this year; we have no legislative power utcr the years to come. ’l‘be As- sociation will hring nu expert here who will spend all ‘his time at the ivorii. together with ten specially trained nurses under the guidance of s supervising uurse. They will Operative irom live celltres in the i-royince and will examine all pill.- ieuts whoprcseiit themselves. They will instruct the patients and do iill in their |l(l\\'\‘.l' to '1ollow the iascs even to ihcir homes. ‘Pliey will enileavoi lo show people ‘how they can take cure oi themselves und how this disease should be looked after, inking it in its early incipient stages when there is a hotter chalice oi effecting u cure. Fortunately‘ tuberculosis is not like cancer; it it ls caught in its incip- ieiii stages it holds oiit more chanc. es of n cure than ii good ‘many oth- e-r discuscs.

'l‘hut ls tlic proposition. i believe it is good, and i oopc that ln a few ycuis ii‘ it gin-s iulo operation, it may icsult in gi-i-zlt bc-uollt to the Province. lt will certainly he one way oi‘ solving our immigration dil- ilculty. ii‘ We i-iiu szivetlic pco- ple ivhoin Wt‘ litirc hcre, it will be iar bcttcr than bringing in i.milil- ruins. ifitllltlllllrlti.)

ruin P1159 ‘L! I v h“, ye“,- ie ulilui tit‘: complied WM“

were ' anon, there were . [nVEiil g mherculualu out l" [ram Tint means that 0' 95 Q1 every telv deaths "fnflf, i, “one by tuber- ro

miueil f

ie death front every eight, if. is one h; shows that tho luliliifiovvuli- we kmm’ s fairly active cani- s be "tuberculosis in U"! "m the past few year.» ' drflnfi education entirely. llsiively iiiliFll money bc ‘"5 gurus show that . ‘ w ures, q, U '“°;l‘:lllguot,,,i-liiis had iin “$11.. deiltll i-iiie from the ndslllllll hits ilecrcusod ‘he- gm m“! my; lftrfinl one in uboiileolnllniiilllurely Shows ‘mproivll of ii thorough nut.- iblliitlwnlpuign- Yo" Wm “It-luring liil‘. war, 8 P1111156 Atltltiriliililil came down m“ inidci- the auspices ot u, 5., and tlicy have been ‘l. _\'o\'il Si-oliii ovori ‘Uoinii-rtiim with the l'ull- “: |]t‘|lilI'|llIt‘lli, 'l‘hcy "MB "m; h. 15117. in Nova Sco- , -.,-,. 17,’. ili-utlis .i'roin Another lllililvl‘ iieiilt with by tllc r" M "t oi l0 000. lsu-iiilnauilei- of lhi: Uppositiiz-ii was thc mimxi], rulir. was f8tllllfliflvfilflllllfle free (‘illllll ilfltil, Ho. iirgueil hey 10000. '|‘lliiI. slioivs ihcithill. the oxpi-nsii of lihc establish- ‘f, thin H,“ lit.‘ donc alonizlincnt o.‘ ibis zlroil should "have been 0' ‘ ' tlivfiiuvcii ‘by ihi- lioniiiliiln (iovi-rn- ob. Iiil,‘ ilt'ill|| ruli- iu lhisluiilnl. l unili-rstilnd, Mr. Silcakcl‘. “mt iii tuberculosis with liiut thurc is u definite regulation ‘can? with the other Prov- iui this point. and that the expeuso u Caniiiiii. and we flu-i iliuuoi conveying thil. veterinary sari;- m "m, ppr 100,000 iii 102i cons must he borne by the Prov- “, yoi-ii siotiu It wits lilFUN Wllflftl tile scheme has biwu ye“- il1‘1l||.~l\\'lt‘.l(, lo’; i-ii curried out. i will leave lily sou. 133; hi iiiiiiiriii. ti in lrii-iiii the Minister o1 Af-Zflliillllllft.‘ i0; in Siisiiiiii-iicuwiu, H; to doul with tliiil. if tiierc is any ..7; in iiritisli (loiiiniblsi, criticism oil the subject that is .|,,,|,. hi" (fflmiilu wilriii answering. xii. ll is triii- l may say lllat this was an un- iive prov- forsccn expenditure on tlic piiri i-i yin-u‘ si-iltizi ii (iuobec, us this (iovernincnt, one that wc could lhighluy-[lituil] 1-1itost'(1i'i\1licl‘- ilot liiivc iiutli-lpiiteil when the l-‘~<- than i'l'llll'l' i-Jdiyziril isliinil tlinntcs wcrc prepared lust y V 34, '1‘hi-.y vury from year u-lid oiic which l think the Premier r; i m,“ ‘hill giving one year rightly sulii in his iiuilglzt SiDOPPlI w our ri-lntiri- position. uild 185l- llltilll tlllollld 11°! b" ‘Jliwitled lii out that were the average up lii the ilrilinilry ilcilcit roiulnn. rate in one year in Canada lt. is ipiitc lruc ihut tho ilrilitiultl‘ ptr 100,000 of population. izolunlu shows the deficit to bu

v mo": W35 0i use 11"‘ "I “yelling-

ii. I ls

Tho ll h, pi-i-liuii

.. 1-.

Disease Free Area

'l‘l

merside by the ever taken

I llflfillltllll.

but our debt has been increasing. it is always increasing and one very Kood index of it is the interest. The interest in will was $50,801. 1920 it was $56,407. R0. ‘ill 1922, $59,070. o0. in 1924. $66,472. since 1919 and I don't know how long before that, when there was

ill 1923 $64.- $69,239.

And I think it must ‘be acknow- ‘edited Limit it is due iio good. finali-

wppluu-se.)

Returned Soldiers

Another matter referred to again by the Lender of the Opposition is returned soldiers. l did not think

go over this again. but it is like a good inauy other subjects,

friends will get up on n public plstfornl and say. “This statement was made on the floor of the iilousa 11ml they couldn't contradict it".

he answered, though it has been answered liiany itiinen before.

turned soldiers the ‘Leader of the] Opposition went over his usual ground today, ‘hilt ii think lii: vvrut ii little too fsr. I ilo ‘not. ‘know; ivlicther the families or ilic nicni whom he mentioned would ithinnki Jilin or anyone else for ileblttingl ilii-lr finirncia/l stuudhig, their fflllL‘ lly history. and everything else, on, ihi: floor oi’ t‘hls House. Ili- ‘lflltl us all iihnilt lihosi- faiiiilliwa; tanil in, "mill-f one man's genealogical troci I'll pin so inucli pathos into “.4 tbzil one would almost think iio was l:i\"n‘1: ill] obituary. When tl-ll 11011.1 nicmbei- is prepnreil to go u... fur 1m‘

"Is He sincere?" tho change that uitrs iuiiilii. lit Sum?

Opposition ri-ferrcil. That change was nlude ilflfl ill January. 15126, iii bye-election wits held there andHhci

you wish, In the Conservative

in that district many years. (Applause). Surelyi pic of Silininersiilo. fully oogizan-t of ‘liil’! change made in that dc- huvc -sui-d_ in effect: “We believe this Government did wisely." That is the only lildicn- tion you can iiikc "ltlilii0dl in Sumniirrsiilo. if lthorP‘ was so illli(‘ll ludllzuntiim about tlilsi dismissal, then tiio pcnplc hail u‘

i

II 144. So our death rate $555911 bill iiigri-e with the Pruni-

y above the average-almost lor‘ in illc -ltclns he presented gr sent above. it can be re- which should ho dciiilctetl irolu ,aiis it has bcn reduced in tliut apparent iicliclt if you want ther Provinces; that ls the to liild tlic real financial standing ior tho your. There are iteinswifi

i- tiii- nulurol urgumient gasoline revenue tax nnd it creillti mt out in Suskuti-hewun of uciirly $5000 on 'llii3li should be taken oil: 1 ilcili-it, as wi-ll us tlic| the sinking

Quill‘! y is! tllicrtu their low tuberculosis is ie. ‘rhi-ro is stunt-thing in cxtrit provision for hut on ihi- other liuud, it is fund. hose two Provinces that are .\ly hon. friend so)“ that n 15 ing the most money in anti- nonscusi- to liilk about real and ult- ulosie work, uot\\‘ithsiuililliig l)lll'f‘lli ilcflcits. hut to 86l- W ""1 act that they liuri- the bust root oi‘ tho mutter You-must coll- ie. so ii is ii niir Hllttlillllilll. to siilcr thcni 111 U111! lii-rill ill View "f tinit it is not ilui- to i-li.n_i_ii__t_li: tho Slllkllil’. i'i_i_l_i[li_ Suppose there lions lllotlv; it is due to pre- was no more money hflffllwfld b)’ on. Tin-y hi-lii-yo iii iiiiit llllll this Government. Then about th= are tl|lt‘lliilll,l.t 1|1I;‘lll‘_\' uiong lllill year 1945. if thfl 9'95"“ ‘Hum l |il'lll‘\'i‘ llll‘l'l' will not hi‘ WGTO f0ll°wldv ‘he Prue“ “PM o’ uiuch ilillvri-ni-i- of opinion llH the Province could be llduldiwd e vulur o1‘ pl'i*\’i'lltl\’0 work in and paid olf thrcuflh ‘h’ medium °7 proviui-c. the sinking ‘funds. which a" "°‘" on a solid basis. -Tlit'l‘tlfllllllil-yi 1:8 ‘one or two which do 110! ll ll ° ililllli. illass specifically. such as the c sillllt-‘lirs in inc ’i‘ubisri-.uio:z-‘Dumb, or me ppincg 01 wales (jol- sochltlon polllt to another 108,.“ which are 011.11 different bas- ii-ng facts-where there is one h,’ “m1 game earlier ones for which ° “"17 '"b°"°"|°ll* l‘ h" the sinking funds arc not adequate. '°“"¢| All)‘ Y9!" 9f Blllfirlmfll‘ liiil olliorwlsc the sinking funds n that time are nine contacts: pro miiilc up on ii ‘proper nutllHYl-‘l hi. wlicrc you have mic ucllvo hum“ m“, Wm My o“ the bonds 1n .\'Ull may tunic-ct nluo iiioru to u oigrtui“ miinboi- of years. The hill from illill (mo. if ‘hGTQwr°y|.|@|-‘ out 1| made annually 100 persons died last year 1°,- gpem must therefore be taken tuberculosis In this Province "no igcgunt; the money must be uiriiui-iiii ilii-iii "uctivo" UHHIIH, put “we to "quit-late the debt at .1’. iiiiiri- i|u~y l|li'4| from it u" "g of the time specified, arid '7 "Pm ma‘ °°°"°" °" "l" the extra provision made for thv ' Wm h‘ 99° ""5 """m"l1 sinking funds should be taken into 1111111. not counting the hund- con-inflation In figuring up the de- wlm are actively affected flt-fleig, 0i course it lii vory lisrii mm“ "mll- for my lion. friends to see the point. ° p'°p°'m°" "l "'9 cflmdlfl‘ because they have no faith i-n stilli- . Tuberculosis Asscclabon 201mg ‘unds. mm,|“m,,,_,. Accord. G°v"""‘°"l l! "lll- "l" '7 W“ ing to tho stulonicilt oi’ thc Louder 9'" 1111 $5000 the Association of "w, Qppoiiition. he considers that Pl" 1111 $20,000, and they will m |_ °_ u. is just as good, for, i" "d ‘hi! $25,000 every year tor purposes of good government. i!

"' the sinking funds. nut l would NS like to draw tn his intention illi-

‘fut-i that those l. O. U'I. WM" the ‘bonds mature, vlvillrnot playithem ‘off. I think tier ore la. o method is the only sunsihic iiud logical one oi‘ dealing with Lin? finances.

slim Cues of Feminine lil- A no Question

Relieved by Lydia B. Pisk- WW“, m, Lu,” on", opp,“

I‘ veleuue- comma.‘ ‘glen be satlsflfdkifola: gnu ‘Gina's;

‘the year we o0 t‘

r’ u, _ __ funds sold the bonds, took thfl ii§'.".‘..-".‘.i‘.i.§. illiihifiiii: m»; 1° ti" W“ t" ""1" our. “in, ‘n JV" my b“; _ 1 out our over draft, and showed our l hsveihgo u) bed every month financial condition to be a coup e nothing ‘mum d1; m; , M of hundred thousand dollars better

dsnd my hum 3i my '07‘ m... we have it new and out in

"it ll l have two children snd,l O. U. for the amount tbs} we de- e ii big lace. lresd ifrplctsd if" 711M197 w” d” * mum‘ PIP" about. Lyd a E. Pinkhsm's t, 4e ‘it, because ws don't “"91" ., table Compound. and than got I'm w but‘ It you pursue his srstl- 500k about itthrou h the mail. l meng’ u, 1mg logical conclusion that '11! husband senttn lion's and I what we could do.

"l! I bottle and then we i: ' In,“ b0?“ said that we tncress-

lrom the shore. I sln fsslgg n ms 1 ("pm u, i”; year ncarly

low and do all my work and am gilohuiiboia i; yfmi take off what gflplltlflfllfld more. ltell my ‘max ‘M on u“, fondm 302,000,

‘. it isLydisE. PinliliamhVer, l" l. . m, expenditure (ei-

. m und umtnuk” may,“ and this liil one ’ H-nd ‘that '91’ mVicros Ricluilmsoll. ‘““°““ " e ""“"' yo“ M“ ,1 go.- irwn. Nova Seotiml. 31° mam] f: it‘: ,‘.'.‘.'.ii’;“:$§.} one

L‘ pfl yB , . '

Dull Psinsin Back If we use not those two mm- to

.. deal with more would be no i11- niss Ont. - I took t i, 015d", E en in risbllltlss. -But we all:

C0111 lid and found at; rs- lht! #11111" "l" "he" w” “n” o ("all e dull, llssv ps ns in tbs

1,31,“,- improvement it must b0 my bsck and‘ s weakness i-Jmnged up n vlltlllldlllllll- "e" ‘ which I suffered for flvs can

hm M M we intro.‘ from our hon. 111011111 " "hit ssh

What Statistics Prove

four Plnkhsmfi Vege-

. . , id. herever v amputee ifillisnfiymtaiitlwii-‘Si... 3V0 ha" always tclmi unit stand. and 1

Pinliii ' suns W Millbs m“ £24». ‘mo: it i. u.- imi, lortcll 1W" M. .

ttertbsal to

(iiiycruinent thiit thcy illsnpprbvcil! oi‘ our action ii-nil would refuse ioi

isltnd n iilan to support us on that‘,

accoililt. They didn't do so, so i think the answer is there. llr» also tiikcs objection to some

[he hlgluviiyflfil’ the uppoliltuionts we mnilc oi’ re. "M's?

turned soldiers. He ‘niontionilil one gentleman as belonging to an affili- e-nlt fumily and siiid thiut when wc

,niaile ilppointiuents Wt‘ uiuile thrmlimsed "9 tram mm" a5 chmmuis-

from rich families. Thai lllfly be the custom with the [liborill party: ‘t is not. ours. A young mun to whom ‘he referred “'85 given‘ the position of Assistant lProvinciiil Secretary‘. but if you ‘bring him in here. and alrk him if he belongs to ii rich family. it will be tho first nu knows about it.

Other Crlilcitsms Answered

My lion. friend i-rlticiscil the ills- milvsal of an official in the School Supply Department, -I wonder If the hnn. gentlcinnn would really like to imeet and discuss the fain- lly h'story and ‘the social stranding and conditions of soino oi’ our em- ployees that wc had ivhcu we cum". ‘lilo office‘! We bud justification, unii vrry igroiiil. justification in iiluiiy i-iii-u-s for ilisnilsslng officials. If he want-s to ileirl with the ‘School Supply particularly ‘l lllily tell lilin shout the conditions we found whim we \\'l!Il|_ in -t'iii~.riv ltud look charge; tbiit tho involi-cs and rr- torils wcro fliitliftlyiltl in that iii-- pilrtnii-ut unilcr the mull whom wn ilisuilsseil. \Vo (roillii go ovor to tlic "hirlvos rhut. worn opt-n to Ibo school i-hililruu and look‘ ‘nit ‘the vrry cheapest kind oi’ ilti-riitilre. ‘hi- i-ilusli flllfl itrilsli tliiii hc hiiil illuceil thori- for ‘tho cillFcnilon of tlii- children. i need not 1:0 flir- thor info the iliulior ‘bore. 1V0 mode ihc change, and we illd wisc. ly unil woil.

Ho even inonrlloils changes nluile in iippoiutincnts iu ‘this ‘iiouse. iio did uoi loll us that 1hr situation was lllf‘ sitinc yvhcii t'liuy wort- lu power, unit that when appointments oi’ roturnI-il soldiers worn ‘being made in the session of 1920 lii this House they ivoro the vory mou who turned rciurucd men ilown. lint Wt‘. do not f‘l‘Kl\l'fl iippoinlniinits of ihut kind il-S‘ of very much lulport- aim-e. It uiwius oully two or three ivcukii’ work iind vory siniill ro- munerulion. We do not regard that us fulfilling our duty. and i would ilriiw this to niy hon. friend's ut- tentlon. if he Is so sollcltous about the welfare of returned soldiers br their families. he has an 0111110"- tunlty not very long ago of recogn- izing them in his own countymfld In s way they should be recognized- He and the former Minister in the McKenzie King Government, when they llsd the appointment of a senator in their own hands. DID THEY RECOMMEND A RETURN- ED SDLDIIH? Ha would Mt lhavs to go vbry fir among his owh followers to find s returned sold- ier. l-Is could st least find an lion- arable gsntfemsn who sent four ions there ,lnd who now slits ls I member of this Houlc. (Applause)

i

ward; returned soldiers lie has on. ly to look to his own conduct. and m will gst a fitting answer to ills remarks- (‘increased spill-W")

Prohibition iProiitbltton has been referred to

gill by the ‘lfllilfll’ of the 099011‘ tics. in» seminal: n mt the

guy-Lg" - wwmmiv, lass lsi-lssnssr-lilem . . v “.~ w“ n "I

Till’. q. rslsr in... u. NI alum-It

‘ln IQZBXGcvernment. 102s was the first ysarilou reuizlrk which hlld appeared 1n and wlth our lleviile lvflvhis the.

i

from n", byedtho iProhihitloil Conrinission unilcr

111 h. l; sincere in his attitude te-‘

iii ot- csivs oils to be token out of the pockets of “°m'£,m,,5u=mx.oi would the people. We say that there is

THE ‘OHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN

see how that c0l'l‘e8lll)lld-S.-'Wh9" he said that the Government bad no jurisdictlbn or responsibility

sion, apart altogether from the

l iiske exception now

t.he press, that we dismissed the

iin-te Prohibition Commission. We

any reduction in interest showmfdid nothing of the ill-Dd. Thflir term 1115i “$91K | Kilt“ head-ll (it Pl-ifllfalvs .

clnx. to 500d. legitimate biislnessimaintiiin they; latcr eve-nfg haveiince. Do you think that additional‘,

cf office had expired, and we ap- pointed a new Commission. And l

'justlfied our appointment, because Tin their viry first year of opera- i-tlon they were able to save $13,000 in prices alone. But my hon. frleuil ‘ion this question, like imsny others. "s inconsistent. it was all right if

ftbe Prohibition _Conimissicn saw

It would he necessary to have to fit Ito return any ‘amount of moneyitell

,to the Liberal ‘Government. but

-i[ ycu'now this Government has no rlglioand Iontenteil people. do not answer it the time 'msy'to ‘Luke one dollar. How any niiiuinll »t'hnt.—-biit the point is tha collie when some one of our Liberu1|can make those statements and just-Y money problem is at the bottom of. ify his attitude as the leader 0i‘ 11. i can under»

party ie more than stand. .'I‘he record of the busincs‘. so far

For that reason the criticism must as the ‘Prohibition Commission isl concerned. ‘is open to the puiilic.| Oil We have mode every endruvor toi this question of employment iio redcurry tho law into

effect. -'l‘he proof is that there have ‘been more prosecutors at work. An extra mun ivlls iappointeil last your in this city, and iu King's Conn-ty lthere ‘wits another luau putt on in addi- tion to those already ailpollsicil. They have proved ‘their good work by the incrcziseil number of coli- vlctions Qbtillneil durin-g l._lie year. if the conditions are not satisfac- tory, I say that we can place. the blame at the door of the place the Government, which its making no honest or sincere sffort- ithe 10L tel" hi‘ the lute IMinisitcr of Customs in the iKlnp; Government to the

this. the question uaiilrirlly raisi:s,‘"°"l~l'"l'Y llmwllllfilalllllllfi "- l9 Pit‘ low “"11 “"5 (‘lllllll-I

rcl the coast of this Province;

'1 1mm only “m, U, my rflkurmngdothcrwlse rum runners would not Govemiiiioui is

U: able to anchor off our shores

"Ho-Side in which .11", pomp“. Oi- UN. and remain there most: of the eum- know tho rccoril

nrcr unmolested, to ply their ns- farious trade. rAppliluse). 'l‘hs‘t in the illlWill‘. This Govern-

poopie we", mp0,] u, pa“ m, [hefllltlli is milking an honest effort will judge properly uuil corrcc genera] fecal-d m- um, G0v,.rn,,,,,_,,,_*to put into cite-cl. Lilo illrohihltlon Vgu mey ana|yzc the answer‘ ihlaw. Hut lilo ‘Libi-riils when ill pow.

to do with tho -l’rohi“.iitioil Act;

11 “.ii; he’ adynmpd ma,“ the pwgthcy wens satisfied to talde money which we hiiro bi-i-u so 1011;; ,1,.,,;Q,|_‘

from them it the rate of $5,000 a year, was that to advance the in- tcrests of Prohibition. Yct they have the hardlbooil ‘ tn ‘rililllfl up now and criticise the opcrzttion of

this Government.

Our Claims Not "Chestnuts"

~plcudlil opportunity of tolling this; ~

There is llll0lllPl‘ important nint- ter which has been lllfdlllllOliltd in the (lehutes this si-‘shiin; that is .t‘ho mutter of our Fcileriil Claims. ‘,'l‘he lmuilcr of the Opposition has ibocn pleased to call itlicui “chest.- l don‘t. wonder iii it. be- peuuse if you examine closely the re- ,cord of ‘the party to which he be- jlongs. they have always been dis-

iTlltly have never made any seri- ‘hi... attempt to present. those claims ‘which are unriuswerzvble and which can only be settled 'by an addition- al increase oi’ subsidy 10 this Pro- vlnce. We ‘know how the late PrP-inicr treats-.ii liil-m; how dur- iilig the yrurs in which he was lend- er of the (iOVEFIIIYIPIII the most lie 0V0!‘ did was write ‘two or three ‘lotions iihoill. them to ‘the former premier of Nora SCOUIL- That [was the wily he pressrd oilr claims. ‘And "l suppose iliy lion. friends ztrc nil inrbileil with ‘the ‘sniine spirit; that spirit has got among them‘ and it comes out. ln the saying 0i‘ the present leader of ithe party- "chestnutsl"

Biit we on this sfd-c of ‘the House Iieliove in illoeo i-lalurs. null have always believed lii tliciu. “We have good reason to do so, ‘because it. ‘is not ver long ago since the pre- pciit Chief Justice of fills Province showed bow much there was in them. His demonstrated to thie ls- isnd and to Canada whether those claims were chestnuts or not! Ho showed that. he was able to realize $100,000 on those chestnuts. and -t'ho Qnnditlons under which that. subsidy wile given has gone fur (.0 fix in our minds that. those islaiins are as good now as they were then. The payment was only a recognlitlon on account, and had they been pressed further by the Bell Government, as they should have been. they might have been Justified long ago.

‘We have further ground for thul. belief in the fitftl. l.liiit Sir llobert illordoil, when ‘Pfllllt! Min’stivr ..f iCiiiladii. recognized one cliilni at ‘ion-st when lie built the cur furry {and ‘Hllililllflllflll those docks at Tormenitine and Borden and begun itiie standardization of our rail- 'wiiys. That wills a recognition oi‘ our claim ‘that the transportation facilities of the lllrovinco had never been wllnl we wore (“lligllilfld ‘to. anil that. the Lorine of the (loufederatlon agreement hail not been carried out. Haven't we good reason. therefore, to ‘believe ‘ini those claim-s. as the record of those two concessions which I .‘hsve cited show very clearly.