PAGE SIX

1 After long

"ALL 1J4. A W"

Now packed

Q

tests we are con-

vinced Aluminum is the best container for tea.

RED ROSE

a A“is good tea”

only in Aluminum.

"anti f. ‘.1 11.. -

Opposition Leader

too last year one 01' sending iner to the West too had the [retrial Wort-ll did not re-

. . but the Govern- - to appoint a young : qt college. and to ‘ l tlisapltointnlent o1 111:1 .\i.rell they sent the $111111)" South to recreation at the ex- 1-:-‘ $14,100 to this corin-

condemned

lunders ‘ thawing up to

lilgle

111T?» sums ul their tinned 1t 111 191s, 1911, 191s, and in

the-

rtiece oi iron in thefiund. The hlathieson Government "e charges also are saved two and a half per cent. by

,'l‘he Accounts show not money blll ‘lust a little l. O. l‘. a deposit re- lceipt, under the loan at 4 percent. ffhat replaced the cold cash; and -the same all the way down for leach succeeding year. There were l. 0. U's for $220.86, #1131930. ‘$112.31. $2.95 $182.71. $211.95 total ling $14,390.57. Not only did they replace the $1500 there in cold cash with 1. O. Us. but there was an ad Iditlonal amount that they had put lthere in order to redeem the bonds lbecause every year the amounts in creased considerably. Altogether fithey replaced not only that $1501 §but they put an additional amount of about $10,000 in 1. 0. D's. alto- gether over $12,000 for the year ‘i915. That was the hiathioson Gov- ernment. And they kept it up year after year. .\ir, Saunders was not taking exception to that, but it it was wrong for the Liberals to do the same thing. the Conservatives should be the last to say anything They began it in 1915; they cou-

l

‘923 when Premier Stewart sold the $150,000 bonds t0 uoutreal firms what did he put in the sinking fund to redeem these bonds? Just i375 in 1. 0- C's. lie put altogether

were bought as a patriotic act by

‘Premier Arsenault. We were then paying 51,4, per cent. on all otrr ov- ertltaft at the bank. That ruoney was borrowed and those bonds were only bearing 5 per cent. They were maturing in 1923. and in 1922 uhese bonds were sold at a consid- lerable premium. and the entire amount was taken back to the Bank ’of hlontreal to pay oil’ the loan, and we had then to our creditnsubstan-

fund the Liberals put in an 1. O. U.

Liberals invariably accepted thei lowest tender; but under this Gov‘ ernment no liberal/need athly, Mr. Saunders cited the cue oGJohn McGuir-k, who tendered (or Project No. 69, Lot 48 road. Thoflth this man's tender-d was 1.11s lowest. he did not get the work because he was a Liberal. . _

The Government had not appoint- ed another Minister oi Aflloulture .n the place oi Hon. Mr. Myers, Mr. Saunders said, because theyavere afraid oi opening another constitu- ency, We ahould have a hilniator on the job, who would ‘be visiting all the corners of the Province, ia- structing the farmers as Mr. Lea did. T_hia waa the department that our people ‘are looking up to, and we have today no head -to that de- partxneut. When the Premier said the Federal agricultural grant of $30,000 was withdrawn and we lost that much revenue, he only told halt the story. This Government got over $14,000 for technical education so they only lost about halt o1‘ the other grant. , The Liberals had purchased :1 clover huller tor the farmers and they supplied a lime crusher at hliminegash which did splendid

streets. Where is that machine t0- day’! The last Mr. Saunders heard it was in the back yard of a strong partisan Conservative, Mr. Keane. dy. Just imagine! Yet the Premier will say, 10h, well, I don't‘ see all)‘, great necessity for having any head‘

to the Department o! Agriculture; That is only on a par with what oc- curred with respect to the ditcher used for the roads- In 1915 it was

the Technical School established

ter and cheese had been deterior- ating in value but under the Liber-

'on some agreement, some reserva-

a

0111115 “hoitnrtroi-rnrown GUARDIAN

1 l-lon, Dr. lllolilllan: Tell 11s about your horafll- ‘ ' ~ MR. flAYrfil-JBS: Int me all)’ that that policy was pursued by U"? uberal Minister and was-a lllllelldld policy. We require standard Pll" and thorough-brad horses for our lament-utility horses. At that P81‘- ticular time the farmers were de- manding it. You can't bfl-Elll l0 e5‘ timate the value oi brlnsllls 111°" horses to this province when y0ll begin talking about dollars and cents. I am satisfied that the farm- ers oi this country will‘ back up that importation of horses. My friend will say you raid $24100 l" a horse, and afterwards sold that horse for less than halt thlll amount. That is no argument 1 8B3 lg the progeny of that horse are distributed over the province. that is the very thing the farmers neod- But, my friends would sleep from now till Doomsday before they would do a thing of that kind. They haven't got the initiative. 1 have heard prominent farmers discuss that policy, and almost invariably said 11 was the prover thllls w d0- .R9ferrlng to the oyster areas, Mr. Saunders said our fishermen have been asking, through hlr. A. E. McLean, to have the Provincial

-. i hi‘ '5 i . .. , _ “PM anzl-‘lagfr f! tn l. O. 1 s m er $29,000 in the vyear work Bu‘ the conservallve‘ wok ' have i923, After all. what harm did it [he crusher and hauled l; m 0-. Government turn over our claims pREMll1ER,STl¢}\Y_.\RT; ‘ll “~35, a1 on the other do? The“ Mud” ma‘ “"9 m?“ teary. for cracking stones on the I0 the ‘Federal mpanmen" 5° m“ T01‘ mall)‘ yellrfl- I money can be swlll 011 the clllll" MR. saurmnrts; The Act was,

tlon of these beds. So far as htr. saunders knew, up to two or three weeks ago this request had not been complied with. This should have been done a your o!‘ tuole 8-50. But no. the Premier wants to (a5

tion, about permission to fish clams for bait. The people are not asking for that. They want these Rich- mond and itslrelrue Bays to be

‘i’ *'l"“-" Bridle‘- PYO- 1 rtr lnt15 edt the weani- creosote piles, tial amount over and above what a‘; u exp“ o brought back to their old time ,Comlnuing‘ m,‘ Saunders mum,‘ d for engineer- we paid for them. 1n the sinking Mn Saunders lauded the work o; standard of production, and they tamed m,“ while “may ll“, Qxflnpl

want the federal Government to

was all very well to say that. this revenue is earmarked for the roads

land worth more? , 1

under the Conservatives.

v HON. DR. McMlbLAN: ls the‘

i MR. SAUNDERS: There are n0 additional improvements, as iar as I know; but 1 do know that the

people have come to me and told;

me that these farms that they paid) a. certain ount of taxes on under; the late lberal administratioud they still have the same land, and, the same farm, no improvements) but today they are paying more. PREMIER STEWART: Dotvt you know a number that are paying! less? 1 11131, SAUNDERS: No, I don't. l It there were‘ any that were pay- ing less, Mr. Saunders argued, they‘ must be good Conservatives. . The Succession Duties tax, Mr.‘ Saunders said, had been increased. and the rate is now as high as 3O per cent. The Premier says that is not correct, that the most we pay ls 15 per cent. But .\ir. Saunders maintained lie was right. He quot-l ed sections of the Act of 1925 tot prove this contention. 1t was a 1't>1'i'| unfair enactment Any clruriiuhlel religious or educational bequest go-l lng outside the Province was 111x011: under this Act. lt was most unfair; That was not the law before. i

back again. The Act in 1894 wu the same as this. and continued for! some years. lt was clrartgetl. Youi come in and put it buck to the, same oltl place.- .1 PREMIER STiliYAllTz 1t is the‘ same as the‘ other Provinces. '1 MR. SAUNDERS: What do l, care about the other Provinces? it‘ is unfair, l believe every merubcrl oi’ the House will agree with that-l

tion under sub set‘. 3 of sec. 8 oi“,

erty of a deceased person liable to, 0!‘

succession duty under the Act. thereof. or any lelzucynl

when a kingdom revolts against

the love oi two youm hearts: when"

Intrigue and trickery attack mom behind, the while swords are bran-

dished In the fore; whtn li-‘i thrill l '

on thrill and patron gasp you'll know you're living the biggest sbow In your lltetlme. Joseph M. Sohenck presents

Prince reward

LAST runes rooAv ' 3.1a, 1 ‘ AND‘, a];

Romance;

= Hardware Co.. u" s not one creosote But the Conservatives took out the . assist in the oyster culture. llle M; l5 (ml $51100, rnder the!

1 br. - or within ten cold cash. while the Liberals took all: §§1l3°§§§“‘f:£;gp;§§i,,°, Continuing the debate on April om a“ me exeymptlon w“ smopm by

‘- 111‘ challenged the Gov- out bonds, The principle is exactly ‘Rammed mere, whlch costlhelween 1st, Mr. Saunders again charged and "may ll, a mm, l,“ n will. and] George

111 refute that statemenL-tlle same- ~11’ it was wrong to take $1000 and 3,000’ and whlch w“ that the gasoline tax had merely l,“ m, gannly and has m, 63mm‘, FQX Ngwg Burr

. 1 .1 1» charging up $372 torlout the $1500 cash it was wrong to dams excepflonally good work Up. been substituted in place of the poll worm $6300 m- gglml, ‘ha, “m, has, RENEW McCtrtcbson; _ < when there was notltake out bonds as well. in both in- m that “me may hm a 8mm deal tax, the only difference being that got m my suovesslm, duly‘ l-mle, ORCHESTRA Screen

'e pile in that bridge/stances. as far as the money was o‘ trouble l“ contromns the flavor the Government is deriving a larg‘ the old act “he (lid no, ha“. m; Version no: an engineer there1COl1C9rl1Bd, it was in the sinking (m. Ghana 1.1m. many yea" our but. er revenue from the gasoline tax. 1t sea 36 says “llml where the prop.‘ Eugene oyBrien

‘APitIL 7, 192},-

but the road patrol system ls part oi the ‘public necessities, the same as schools, etc., and if not. paid out o1‘ this tax would have to come out of genera-l revenue. The fact that the gasoline tait 1s earmarked does not make i1. any less a tax. 1r it were so, why do they not earmark

any part

.~ the \v;1_vtlre money doing what they did. Had we taken

is Summerslde or city of Charlotte- 1111- l-‘1-ol11l1i1ion C-omrnls- town bond or debenture and put it citing u salary- of in the sinking fund. that would their services was have come within the provision oi’ . Saunders had just the Statute. But these 1. 0. Li's §-=1t.11g the ProvincialWere negotiable instruments, and

als the butter and cheese malters were brought in to the dairy cot1rs- ea at the Technical School, and im- provement in dairy products follow- ed. The Premier claims that .\ir. McDonald, the present inspector, is entitled to a large share or credit.

charge or" annuity l1z1y11hlt\ out oil

the same. goes to any person rosid-lllllilt-t uru us high as 30 per chill-lint‘ .\ir, Saunders to point the way- iug otrt of the province, the duty and tho (lover-irritant speakers took"1‘hc people would be glad ioltuow payable on the amount or ptlrilmllisstle with hint uutl said it. was only that notwithstanding the small going to such person shall be dotr-‘l; per cent. size oi the Opposition they had at ble the amounthereiubeiorc speci- MLEMLER STE\\'.-\RT: least secured this favorable result fled." This. in other words, was :1 not correct. ln conclusion Mr. Saunders all-

Lhe present ed that 4t in. who were r , . charged and the‘ i 1 . their places had not bet-u

- 1v--.t- rt-c

That is

v t 1 s ' .~1 “M” mumdxi" rm“ hulls at the office oilthe entire province is liable to re- “L Saunders had 110mm; lo say. lf-‘ll- 7111-‘ ‘YRS ullotlelllql-‘Nem i-llelll- "-15 U-‘le 581119 a! 8 D10‘ aglylngt Mr, McDonald. He was a the 15nd u! 3M lncilme m!» ma‘ double l5 per cent tux, or thirty .\l1'. Saunders rurtiutztineti that the trounced that the Liberal partl 1111.1 improper. and themissory note; the whole assets of cheese man o“, i“ the we“ (m. 250118)’ 1116 980919 W"! P981119 U19)’ per cent. 511111111». said so. would stand by and adhere to tlr Iare not paying anything? The lpollli HON. Iill. .\ici'1lli.I..\N: You The reduction o1‘ 111x011 urmouuc- Prohibition Law with such amen

1s 11 right to askjthe Province are behind them. ._.oa,.s_ in“, ma,‘ n 0- cheese w“ t-ry tlollar “first security could be better. Mr. ins b,,s_n,s5_ Mlgwhgn experience - . I11 1S‘ the way Saunders would not say that It was m“ h, mm, m “nhuq. nmkingq The 11 A11 1s being made-the beabthln-q to do, to take out people ,,mle,.$[nn\l that ‘he im_

m” §mkm9 “ma” H‘ mu“ idml‘ prominent tn our dairy industry‘ m" “km m’ in‘ m“ ‘t i‘ m“ m“ pr°per meflmd" has been the toszfl o1‘ education. ‘xllielfiillt! the purchase (‘Aillllflllfle-l. Leaally, lhc Llberala canled on “n, sclfcral year“ But; l‘.111.11l_111.<111 (‘omrnrssiotr of W": not witlim their rights, norlthe prénller m“ l,‘ “Mm an the m‘ "i “imllqlmr fang? of the were m. conugrvluve" i" ‘Hang credit for the Conservative (lovern- l ltl1e.1_un1es_ which was "l" FMMY- H9 W°ll|ti Grant that. mam because ‘he’, h“, ‘he (om. lrnrirersitlc 11y the Cus- _But from a standpoint»! business, slgm to appoln, ML Azvonald‘

111 m‘ and“! m,» moml, 1t was good business in both cases. The Government-s pwfl:‘ty to 1m, l-"Lfllll"! “'35 illlel”. Th?‘ did ‘an aflec‘ ma‘ 113mm‘ prove the breed o1 cattle. etc" is a‘ _ _‘_ '|l=lll°lll3i°_“‘ll ll)’ Tmémls zit: t 37"“ srumiie“ crim" very worthy one, .\lr. Saunders said . unr-rurucnt truiscr eu e1. 't at par cu ar l me t ey but ma! “.38 stalled under the bu» - 111111 illztcerl in bond in had an overdraft of $300,000 due at an“ by M“ w_ w Lea He m‘

l l‘ richly“ f1. 11s tluest on b ’ d- ] all‘ eholfer‘ “If _ r herd which 1111'. Lea placed at Fal- 111. 11111111011 Qornmls; y ong u rat t c) dd t ey would conwood farm where they had my

11111 pttrrlrttse- seized be reducing the loan at the bank tore only Ma scrub herdrqtlongralsu I

they might be called" which werel 1 not paying for their feed. 1n the

tlrstyear the ilolsteins were ahlel

to produce ~17 pounds of milk a day.‘

as against 27 pounds. Today the re?

suit is that we have some oi the! a

t1 11121;. lle had not askedllfl 3100.000 and increasing the other greatest producers, not only in this!

1.11111 lf1215.\\‘:ts11't that uito 5400.000. The aggregate total Province but in Canada. The Gov-.

agreed tn all that. ed in the Frontier's budget speech merits as may bedeomed

.\ir. Sillllltifils‘ said lie wislivtl to .\l1'. Siruirders characterized as mer- to majte its administration n1 Show illlli will" 11¢‘ illlll still-Hi trbmrt ely 1m imitation o1“wht1t he (Mr. workaille, and also that a reduct 1' U"? (lllly W511i! $10 Der cent. was cnr- Qiunders) 111111 nnrtounced a fowlbe mode iu tho sale price oi liquort 'ect. lie always 111111; cure m lu- ex- 11:13:: lwiurt- 11>- the Liberal policyfltkpplauso from the Oppositlol “filly lit-Kilt in l'l‘i-'Ill‘li to :111_\j state- The Guvcrririit-rrt was simply iol treats.) . merits ho made 11110111 fimtncc. and lowing the beaten path or‘ the ‘Lib-i .\‘lr. Saunders was followed in tht 100k his fiklllvs from 11111 Public crul lmlicy. lt had ultvayvs been tho Budget debate by Hon. Dr. McMll 59901111“ l T0001’ lllt‘ strccession czlsc, it seems worth jwltlle after alllan.

Mr, Saunders wished to make was that the Conservatives are taking more money out oi’ the people's pockets in taxes than the Liberals did. They claim they did not in- crease the land tax, but hir. Saun- ders happened to know where land valued at a certain rate under thc Liberals is paying more taxes today

side, who yvrls , oliicral and 1 1-

vvas discharged

‘Government. lie another returned never got any land. That was replace such a l wasn't i1? .\:1 Sheriff Robert

; Mr. Saunders 1 ' turned mt-rt \\'(*1‘t~ d _ civilians who hard 111-"-

placed in their jobs. Mr. Saunders 1111:1111

Lieutenant Governor" .\l1.

[bill ‘oi $2.000, who .1;1tl 1 1 ~

ask tho country to pay

when a house was

him which he did 11.1

l Saunders lrtttl been told

'_ > ZPromier Bell and 111-. w. " that this bill cuuie. ilvf c1ttiyo(four1cil 111111 doWll. He was pr»- ‘stdttitory- dt-clarn" lfromihese zentlw to 11131111111111. .\lr

1" 111 his question? would still be $500,000.

it .\"1‘l-J\\'.»\RT: A very .\1r. Saunders again defended the ernment today can sell those cattic' and get a tar better price than was

~11 You itave no right Bell Government Poll Tax as fair -. imrs beyond the year in and equitable. 1t was not. against. ~ iequests are made. m- llle veer man. but against every knows very well the man in the Province, Men were re- dry rule. ceiving the benefits oi the various lllrtlcrs. quoted an Ottawa lllfovillcilll expenditures and were llmi i119 iluardlan slallng not contributing one cent to the id ‘or them "Eddie James" had a; [he P.ovin<~iz1l Trcastrry. They were pa . ' _ izurc at Strmmersitlo in sending their children to school, Famggvgg: ggflrilllsgofvtrzhgig: a5 get less than 4.000 bushels o! roots and vegetables. ln 1923 they got over 10,000 ‘bushels-Awe and a half times as much. This was be- cause they had a head to the De- partment of Agriculture. The Lib-

pro riled t1.~:1-. by

. . uses of liquor on lmanl‘ getting tire ucrrtlfits of 011l- rggdg 1~tt.1!i11_.. in lion. \\'. l1. Etiler, Min- ttntl publrc 1111111105, all for nothing. 111' Vustorns. After release by '1 mlay-vvltlr 1311- Poll Tax removed. < 1 _ the ,s'[‘h1'1(t]]Q|' was sold by they go acott irtc without paying a t1 11ers in 1hr- P, l; l_ pl-Uhlhl. single cent, it is a. most disgraceful (‘oinirilss-ion. No infoimallon thing, that such a condition should

l1‘- o .1

rod also 1 :1 11111 , v3.- lll,;lllllll]r l - l0 ll l l prevail. The Conserv tives b ii h- Z1 Sh.” Varllllflll (100101 11y ' .111 111.-,~.11-;:1 ti-Tat- ,.11.i01:a1§s Perot: ed the tax but they przrgiszd em“ also procured over 100 pure h‘ j ell! Government r01". i111: 1111 l1-,1.-:~ _l._.»l,,,,/l1i.’,5 ("lstlg ‘m- m (ll l , yvhlle ll was on the statue books’ bled bacon h0g8, which tYIBY d1!" ’ “i551” ‘ation’ ‘m "‘ 3M1 W5 “h” hi" ‘s 11 ‘um’ wrinkle-er‘ the iirtfniiir to wile" 9""? 5lll81e dollar 0r n‘, Qllbultid ttlirroulifllboutl (t)? ‘Province. uh: ‘ ' '. r. a. 9- era rutnissioner "M"...